Two positions each contain $5,000 of stock. One has an entry at 50 and a planned exit at 48. The other enters at 25 with an exit reference at 22. The invested amounts match, but the planned price losses are $200 and $600. Van Tharp’s position-sizing framework makes that difference explicit before the next trade begins.
Equal capital and equal risk are different allocations. A useful comparison needs the entry, the exit reference and the number of units, followed by an honest account of what can happen when the actual fill differs. The examples here are hypothetical and independently constructed.
Van Tharp gives initial risk a common unit
The Van Tharp Institute’s sizing explanation connects position size to a cash risk budget divided by risk per unit. Tharp’s short lesson on R and R-multiples uses initial risk as the reference for expressing subsequent outcomes.
That common unit permits comparisons across trades with different prices and cash amounts. Expectancy can be described as the mean outcome in R over a sample. The sample average doesn’t promise the next trade’s result, and a planned stop doesn’t guarantee that a loss ends at minus 1R.
In the opening example, the first position’s $200 planned loss and the second’s $600 planned loss make the distinction concrete. Normalising them requires changing share counts, and those changed counts also alter the cash committed to each position.
Start with the distance, then calculate the units
The first opening position holds 100 shares at 50. A two-point distance to 48 creates $200 of planned price risk. The second holds 200 shares at 25, and its three-point distance to 22 creates $600. The second position risks three times as much under those assumptions.
If an illustrative budget is $300 per position, the first calculation permits 150 shares and the second permits 100. Their capital values become $7,500 and $2,500. The planned risk is equal despite the different invested amounts.
I would compare the $300 plans before comparing the capital weights. The 150-share position looks larger in dollars, while the 100-share position has a wider adverse distance per share. Both pieces are necessary to understand the exposure.
The ATR bands and swing stops guide offers related background on price movement and exit references. Choosing an exit solely to obtain a desired share count reverses the analysis and creates a different trade.
R stays tied to the original plan
Suppose 150 shares enter at 50 with an original exit reference at 48. Initial risk is $300, so a $600 gain equals 2R and a $150 loss equals minus 0.5R. The denominator remains the original $300.
If the stop later moves to 49, remaining planned price risk from entry falls to $150. Redefining R as that new amount would turn the same $600 gain into 4R without changing the trade’s profit. The apparent improvement would come entirely from changing the denominator.
A journal can record current exposure separately while preserving initial R for performance comparison. That avoids confusion between the risk still open and the unit used to describe the trade’s total outcome.
The same care applies after a partial exit. If half the position closes, the remaining units have a smaller cash exposure, but the completed trade’s final R-multiple still needs the original definition. Otherwise, two journals can report different multiples for identical transactions.
A stop can be crossed before an exit can occur
Return to the 150 shares at 50. If an overnight event produces an available exit at 46.50, the price loss is $525 before costs. Relative to the $300 initial plan, that is minus 1.75R.
I keep minus 1.75R in the distribution rather than replacing it with the planned minus 1R. The larger loss is exactly the information the sizing analysis needs. Capping it in the record would make the method look safer than the assumed execution permits.
Commissions and slippage also need a stated treatment. A $15 total cost adds 0.05R when R is $300. A gross minus 1R loss becomes minus 1.05R after that cost. Smaller planned risk can make fixed costs a larger share of R.
The volatility stop guide describes another way to frame a moving reference. No indicator can ensure continuous prices or create liquidity at the intended level during a disruption.
A high win rate can still leave a negative average
Consider ten hypothetical trades: seven gain 0.5R each and three lose 1.5R each. The winners contribute 3.5R; the losers subtract 4.5R. Total result is minus 1R, or minus 0.10R per trade, despite a 70% win rate.
Another ten-trade set contains four gains of 2R and six losses of 1R. Its gross total is 2R, averaging 0.20R. The second set wins less often and has a higher average outcome under the chosen figures.
Neither miniature sample establishes a durable edge. The numbers simply show why frequency and magnitude must appear together. A small set can also be dominated by one unusual observation, making its mean unstable.
A research report would retain each trade’s initial-risk definition, net result and any departures from the intended execution. Mixing gross and net outcomes or changing the risk denominator between trades would weaken the comparison before statistical questions even begin.
The same R sequence can create different cash paths
Start with a hypothetical $10,000 account and four consecutive minus 1R trades. With a fixed $100 initial risk on each, the balance falls to $9,600 before costs. With 1% of current equity at risk each time, it becomes $10,000 multiplied by 0.99 four times, or approximately $9,605.96.
At 5% of current equity, the same four losses reduce the balance to approximately $8,145.06. The trade sequence hasn’t changed; the sizing rule has. The higher fraction produces a much larger decline.
These selected percentages are comparisons, not recommended risk budgets. They omit gaps, simultaneous positions and costs. Their purpose is to show how a sizing convention transforms a sequence of trade outcomes into an account path.
The Ralph Vince profile offers related reading on position sizing. A theoretical allocation calculation is only as useful as its assumptions about the distribution and dependence of outcomes.
Concurrent trades don’t wait politely in line
A sequential example assumes one trade finishes before the next begins. Suppose instead that five positions are open together, each with $300 of planned risk. Their aggregate planned amount is $1,500, and a common shock can affect all five at once.
If three lose 1R and two lose 2R because of gaps, the combined loss is 7R on the shared $300 unit, or $2,100. Calling each individual position modest wouldn’t describe the whole account’s exposure.
Different instruments can still share the same economic sensitivity. A portfolio record needs to consider those relationships, along with the possibility that correlations change during stress. Five tickers don’t necessarily provide five independent outcomes.
The order of profits and losses also affects decisions when withdrawals, margin requirements or changing position sizes intervene. A simple average R can be useful while leaving those path-dependent constraints outside its scope.
A portfolio review can therefore retain two records: each trade expressed in its own initial R, and the cash exposure across all open positions at each date. The first supports comparisons among trades. The second shows which losses could arrive together and whether the account could fund them.
A sample needs room for uncertainty
Imagine a 20-trade sample averaging 0.30R, with one 8R winner. Removing that one observation subtracts 8R from a total of 6R, leaving minus 2R across the other 19 trades. Their average is about minus 0.105R.
The large winner may be central to the intended strategy. Removing it isn’t automatically a fair estimate of future performance. The calculation does reveal dependence on an uncommon event and raises questions about how often such opportunities occur and whether they can be executed.
The Ulcer Index guide offers another view of the account’s drawdown experience. Mean R, cash return and drawdown describe different aspects of the record. None supplies an optimal position size from a small sample by itself.
Books and the editions behind the titles
The linked Trade Your Way to Financial Freedom is the second edition, and Super Trader is the expanded second edition. Both verified bindings are hardcover. Neither title turns a sizing exercise into a guarantee of financial freedom.
Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
Trade Your Way to Financial Freedom (second edition) by Van K. Tharp. Hardcover edition.
(US) Trade Your Way to Financial Freedom (second edition)
(UK) Trade Your Way to Financial Freedom (second edition)
(DE) Trade Your Way to Financial Freedom (second edition)
Super Trader (expanded second edition) by Van K. Tharp. Hardcover edition.
(US) Super Trader (expanded second edition)
(UK) Super Trader (expanded second edition)
(DE) Super Trader (expanded second edition)
Keep the initial denominator honest
The original $300 risk plan gives the trade a stable measuring unit. The later minus 1.75R loss, partial exits and changing open exposure can all be recorded without rewriting that denominator.
Tharp’s framework makes the connection between units, outcomes and account risk easier to inspect. Its value depends on retaining the uncomfortable observations as faithfully as the profitable ones.
Learn the pattern. Ride the trend. Keep the gains.
Educational content only. Not investment advice. Trading involves risk. You are responsible for your decisions.
Get the free Market Wisdom e-book
Join Trends and Breakouts — historical winners, breakout studies, and risk lessons. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.
