Steve Burns: Turn Trading Lessons into Testable Rules

A journal says “followed the trend” beside a profitable trade and “bad market” beside a losing one. Neither entry explains what the trader actually did. Steve Burns’s educational focus on systems, risk and psychology is useful as a starting point for replacing those labels with decisions that can be examined.

A clear rule identifies the information available, the action it permits and the condition that ends the position. You’re then able to compare a decision with what the rule allowed. Its outcome becomes evidence about that rule instead of an invitation to rewrite the explanation. The fictional exercises below show how that distinction changes a review.

Steve Burns places systems beside behaviour and risk

New Trader University identifies Burns as the founder of New Trader U in 2011 and frames its education around psychology, risk management and systems. His reading-order article presents books addressing different parts of that education, including coauthored material.

These sources establish the teaching focus. The performance of any particular indicator combination remains a separate research question. The rules and numbers here are independently constructed illustrations, not Burns’s personal system.

The exercise below starts with a prior high at 50 and a session that reaches 50.40 but closes at 49.80. Whether that qualifies is a specific question a written system can answer before the subsequent result appears.

Replace a slogan with a complete observation

Consider the phrase “enter when price is strong.” One illustrative definition could require a daily close above the highest high of the previous ten completed sessions. If that high is 50, a session reaching 50.40 and closing at 49.80 fails the closing condition.

An alternative rule based on any intraday trade above 50 would qualify. The difference matters even if both traders describe their action as a breakout. They’re definitions whose samples, fills and outcomes can diverge.

I’d write down the 50.40 high and 49.80 close together because they expose the ambiguity in the original slogan. A record containing only the successful crossing would make the closing rule appear to have signalled when it hadn’t.

The market structure guide helps describe the setting. The ten-session window’s an illustrative choice; a research process would need to evaluate it without choosing the best-looking setting after every result.

An average can be clear without being predictive

Suppose a study adds a condition that the close must be above a five-session simple average. The five closes are 46, 47, 48, 49 and 50, giving an average of 48. The final close is above it, so it’s a qualifying observation under that part of the rule.

A clear rule can still be useless. The filter might remove losing signals, profitable signals or both. A comparison with the same entry and exit rules but without the filter would help reveal its contribution in the selected sample.

There’s another practical issue: the final close of 50 is included in the average. A system using that close can’t assume it knew the completed value earlier in the session. The timing of the order and the assumed fill need to respect that information sequence.

The simple moving average guide explains the calculation. A moving-average lesson becomes testable only when its implementation includes those details. Those implementation details remain necessary even with several averages on the chart.

Planned risk connects the rule to the account

Imagine a hypothetical entry at 50.20 and a planned exit at 48.20. The two-point distance creates $200 of price risk for 100 shares. If the actual entry slips to 50.70, the same share count creates $250 of planned risk to the unchanged exit.

That’s a $50 execution consequence, even though the chart setup may be unchanged. A study that records the planned entry as the actual fill would understate the exposure and overstate the eventual result.

I’d keep planned and actual entry prices in separate columns because the 50.20-to-50.70 difference is large relative to the two-point risk distance. Small-looking slippage can matter when the system’s intended margin is narrow.

An overnight gap can make the realised loss larger again. An exit at 47 would lose $370 on 100 shares entered at 50.70, before costs. The planned exit defines the intended response, while the available fill determines the realised loss.

A good result can contain a poor decision

Suppose the written plan permits an entry after a qualifying close. A trader enters early at 49.50 because the chart looks promising. The market later closes above 50 and eventually reaches 54. In this example, it’s the early entry that earns more than the planned version.

That profitable deviation can become a research question. It’s one case in a comparison that needs both qualifying and failed early entries. The comparison also needs cases where price looked promising intraday and then failed to qualify at the close.

There’s a reverse situation too. A correctly executed trade can lose at the planned exit. Judging the decision solely by its result would classify the profitable deviation as sound and the compliant loss as an error, regardless of the underlying process.

The Ed Seykota profile offers related reading on consistent rules. A complete journal can preserve both process and outcome, allowing each to be evaluated without using one as a substitute for the other.

Expectancy needs the losses and the costs

Take a fictional set of 50 trades. Twenty winners average 2R and 30 losers average minus 1R, where R is initial planned risk. Total gross result is 40R minus 30R, or 10R. The mean is 0.20R per trade despite a 40% win rate.

At an average cost of 0.15R per completed trade, total costs consume 7.5R. The net mean becomes 0.05R. That much smaller figure is sensitive to modest errors in fill assumptions or a few additional adverse outcomes.

If the average winner falls from 2R to 1.5R while everything else remains unchanged, gross expectancy becomes zero. It’s still a 40% win rate. Describing performance with the win percentage alone would miss the entire deterioration.

These numbers demonstrate arithmetic, not an estimate of any Burns strategy. A sample of 50 also leaves considerable uncertainty about future results. The same clear rules can encounter a different distribution in another period. That’s why the sample mean remains an estimate, and it’s useful to preserve the uncertainty beside it.

A habit needs a specific moment to operate

A general intention to “be disciplined” is difficult to review. A concrete habit might be recording the entry, exit reference and share count before an order is placed. In the fictional 50.20 example, that record would preserve the original two-point distance.

If the actual fill is 50.70, the discrepancy becomes visible immediately. If the exit reference later moves to 47.20, the journal can show whether the plan allowed that change. It’s a way to preserve the decision sequence while the information is still fresh.

There are practical limits. A handwritten note may be too slow for some methods, while a fully automated method may need logs rather than prose. The form can differ as long as you’re recording the relevant information before the outcome is known.

A useful review also distinguishes a missing record from a verified compliant action. Silence in the journal leaves a gap in the evidence about whether the rule was followed.

Changing the system creates a new comparison

Suppose ten losing trades prompt the addition of a volume filter. If that filter was selected because it removes eight of those ten losses, its apparent benefit is partly a product of the selection process. The same examples have helped design and evaluate the rule.

A later sample that wasn’t used to select the filter offers a more informative check. Even then, repeatedly modifying the filter after inspecting that sample gradually turns it into development data too.

The historical chart study guide provides a related way to organise examples. A useful archive includes ordinary and failed setups, along with the striking winners that are easier to remember.

The change log can record the old definition, the proposed addition and the reason for testing it. That’s what makes it possible to compare versions without pretending the current rules generated every historical result.

Books and the editions behind the titles

These titles cover different parts of a trading education, several coauthored with Holly Burns. The two-point stop-distance example gives a concrete question to carry into The Ultimate Trading Risk Management Guide: how does a changed fill alter the original cash-risk calculation? New Trader Rich Trader 2 is a separate sequel, and the titles below are not evidence of promised returns.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

New Trader Rich Trader by Steve Burns. Paperback edition.

(US) New Trader Rich Trader

New Trader Rich Trader 2 by Steve Burns and Holly Burns. Paperback edition.

(US) New Trader Rich Trader 2

Moving Averages 101 by Steve Burns and Holly Burns. Paperback edition.

(US) Moving Averages 101

Buy Signals Sell Signals by Steve Burns and Holly Burns. Paperback edition.

(US) Buy Signals Sell Signals

The Ultimate Trading Risk Management Guide by Steve Burns and Holly Burns. Paperback edition.

(US) The Ultimate Trading Risk Management Guide
(DE) The Ultimate Trading Risk Management Guide

Make the next journal entry answerable

“Closed above the prior ten-session high of 50, actual entry 50.70, original exit reference 48.20” gives the review something concrete. It exposes the difference between the signal and the fill and makes later changes visible.

That’s a practical use of Burns’s focus on systems, risk and behaviour. Education supplies questions and methods of examination. The trader’s record still has to establish what was done and whether the chosen rules justify continued confidence.

Learn the pattern. Ride the trend. Keep the gains.

Educational content only. Not investment advice. Trading involves risk. You are responsible for your decisions.

Get the free Market Wisdom e-book

Join Trends and Breakouts — historical winners, breakout studies, and risk lessons. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.